|
|
TEXTBOOKS OUTLINE
LAPTOPS AND CD-ROM/DVD TEXTBOOKS FOR STUDENTS INSTEAD OF REGULAR TEXTBOOKS OUTLINE
PARAGRAPH Well I feel that students think textbooks are like the bible. The bible is like the written word and what in that textbook is correct no matter what. Although we can't 100% stop errors from getting into text books we can put up some measures to get book manufactures to put a whole lot less in them. Here is one example as to why I think that textbooks are like the bible. Lets say student A is out sick out while teacher B goes over a mistake in the textbook. Student A comes back to the class and then takes a test on the same day he comes back to class on the material learned which does include the mistake that teacher B went over. Student A, not knowing of the mistake put down the 100% correct info from the book. Do you give the student credit for getting the wrong answer??? Do you punish the kid for putting down the wrong answer??? What is your plan of action??? That example alone is why textbooks should be held to the highest of standards. The teacher chooses the book and the student is going to wind up reading the book as a homework assignment anyway so errors in books are useless. I will always say that the teacher is the number one set facto standard you should always go by until textbooks are at like 100% error free which may never happen. I do not need my textbook to have political correctness slapped onto them. I do think that doing this is censorship and it does need to be stopped. Sure I will agree that a school population is very diverse in the race department but that should not stop a book to be worded one way. A company producing a book could have a version that is political correct and one that is not. I am not a fan of this, but I can accept this. The teacher is in 100% contol over what textbook they want under my plan and that is the proper thing to do, not the state or school district should have any control over this. If a manufacture of a textbook creates a book that is 100% un-sellable at the end of the semester or school year they should be ashamed of themselves no matter how much the book costs. A better thing to do is for the manufacture of the textbook to create the material that would cause the book to be un-sellable for the teacher to buy and the teacher can then hand it out to the students. I do not think that textbooks should be limited in the amount of pages that it does need to teach the material for a class. The state of California tried to pass a law saying that textbooks need to be no bigger than 200 pages. It has been put on the back burner at least for now which is a good thing. I am a person though that does not really like to carry a textbook that is over 750 pages in size though. I love the idea of creating downloadable college textbooks free with ads. The one textbook that I looked at with ads was not bad looking at all. It will need backing of big college textbook makers though, but anything to lower the cost of a college education is fine by me. Textbooks do need to be changed like every 4 years for certain courses. I don't want students reading outdated material and we all know books like these can't last forever. Textbook manufactures need to tell the teachers up front how much the book is going to cost, shelf life of the book, and a complete comparison between the new and older additions, etc… It is only fair. The companies like to leave this information out so they can get more money from the people that get to buy the book which stinks. In any classroom each student must have a textbook for the subject unless the teacher does not use a book for that subject. This is very important because if you do not have enough books for a class, then how are you going to easily give out homework form a book. If a classroom only has enough textbooks for half a class, I see no good way you can assign out homework for that textbook. It is not good to assign homework to half the class one day then assign it to the rest of class the next day because cheating can occur and will occur on this and that is no good. It is also not good for learning if you only have books for half a class as well. I did not come up with the idea to use laptops and Cd-roms/DVD for textbooks originally, the state of Texas did that, but I really do like it. I know it will be really expensive to start out this idea but the cost of one cd-rom or DVD to produce is like 1 buck and much cheaper than a textbook. Another pro to doing this is it is easy to mark up this kind of textbook because when a student hands the book back to the teacher it will be like the book is 100% untouched. One other nice pro to this is changing from one edition of the book to another will be a whole lot cheaper. The main cons to this is idea is cost of running a laptop for the student and what happens if the laptop winds up with a problem. Q&A NA. SOURCES Carey, Bridget "School of thought: Why aren't e-textbooks
selling?" Miami Herald (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. January 23, 2007 Stern, Eric "Textbook gripe: Buy high, sell low" Sacramento
Bee (2006) n. pag: B1. Online. Internet. December 16, 2006 Silverstein, Stuart "When you can't afford to go
buy the book" LA Times (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. November 7, 2006 Goolsby, Kathy A."Schools toss aside texts for e-books"
Dalls Morning News (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. November 4, 2006 Owuor, Elizabeth "Online college texts are free,
but not free from ads"
Christian Science Monitor (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. October
12, 2006 Weir, William"A Textbook Case Of Revisiting History" Hardtford
Courant (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. Spetember 5, 2006 Lloyd, Marion "Mexico adds sex to school syllabus"
Houston Chronicle (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. Augusy 23, 2006 Marklein, Mary Beth, and Beth Walton"Costly textbooks
get a closer look" USA Today (2006) n.
pag. Online. Internet. August 16, 2006 Marklein, Mary Beth, and Beth Walton "Rewriting the book
battle" USAToday (2006) n. pag. Online.
Internet. August 16, 2006 "Whole new universe challenges textbook writers" CNN.com
& AP (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. August 16, 2006 Pope, Justin "Textbooks Free - With Ads" Hartford
Courant (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. August 16, 2006 Schemo, Diana Jean "Schoolbooks Are Given F’s
in Originality" New York Times (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. July
13, 2006 Available:
O'neill James M."Publishers, colleges binding students
to high book prices" Dallas Morning News (2006) n. pag. Online.
Internet. June 12, 2006 Rado, Diane, and Beatriz Cholo "Turnaround on textbooks" Chicago
Tribune
(2006) n. pag.Online. Internet.April 20, 2006 Rado Diane, and Ana Beatriz Cholo"Aging textbooks
fail Illinois kids" Chicago
Tribune (2006)
n. pag. Online. Internet. April 16, 2006 "Textbook sticker shock" Chicago Tribune (2006) n. pag.
Online. Internet. April 17, 2006 O'Neil, John "Getting Textbooks Cheaper From India" New
York Times (2006)
n. pag. Online. Internet. March 29, 2006 Reitz, Stephanie "Lawmakers Hit Cost Of
Textbooks" Hartford
Courant (2006)
n. pag. Online. Internet. March 27, 2006 Parker, Ray "Online textbooks help Gilbert district
save"
Arizaona Republic (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. February 22, 2006 "E-textbook demand slow despite comfort with technology"
CNN.com & AP (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. February 16,
2006 Kinzie, Susan "Swelling Textbook Costs Have
College Students Saying 'Pass'"
Washington Post (2006) n pag: A01 January 23, 3006 Krieger, Lisa M. "Mix 'n' match textbooks: lower prices,
high utility" San Jose Mercury (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. January
20, 2006 Moran, Chris "Textbooks to be rented at college" San
Diego Union-Tribune (2006) n. pag. Online. Internet. January 4, 2006 Gustin, Georgina "Every 7th-grader in Illinois should
get a laptop, official proposes" St. Louis Post Dispatch (2006) n. pag. Online.
Internet. January 2, 2006 Hobbs. Tawnell D. "Textbooks collected
midyear" Dallas
Morning News (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. December 29, 2005 Heredia, Christopher "Easing textbook
sticker shock" San
Francisco Chronicle (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. November 4, 2005 "Romney proposes giving laptops to most students" Boston
Globe (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. September 23, 2005 Sykes, Shinika A. "Tab for textbooks towers"
Salt Lake Tribune (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. August 26, 2005 "Arizona high school boots textbooks in favor of iBooks"
Arizonia Republic & AP (2005) n. pag. onlijne. Internet. August 19, 2005 Pope, Justin "Hikes are double U.S. inflation rate"
San Diego Union-Tribune & AP (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. August
16,
2005 "College Textbooks
Enhanced Offerings
Appear to Drive
Recent Price
Increases" GAO (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. July 2005 Peyser, Andrea "Math Manual doesn't add up" New
York Post & Yahoo.com (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet.
July 19, 2005 Sanders, Jim "Textbook size won't shrink" Sacramento
Bee (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. July 12, 2005 "Arizona school will not use textbooks" Detroit
News &
AP (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. July 11, 2005 Rosenhall, Laurel "Some schools fail textbook
test" Sacramento
Bee (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. June 12, 2005 Sanders, Jim "Assembly says shorter books would
help kids" Sacramento
Bee (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. May 27, 2005 Harrison, Steve "Textbook case of obsolescence?"
Miami Herald (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. May 25, 2005 "Students surfing Net for textbook deals" CNN.com & AP (2005)
n. pag. Online. Internet. April 7, 2005 Brooks, Karen "Perot pushes technology for schools" Dallas
News (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. March 15, 2005 Jones, Andrea "Forum examines cost of college
textbooks" Atlanta
Journal-Constitution (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. February 15, 2005 Yang, Eleanor "College textbook price report
stirs dispute" San
Diego Tribune-Union (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. February 2,
2005 Rube, Kate "Rip-off 101: 2nd Edition How The Current Practices
Of The Textbook Industry Drive Up The Cost Of College Textbooks" PIRG.org (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. February 1, 2005 Robertson, Gary "Taking aim at textbook market" Richmond
Times-Dispatch (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. January
25, 2005 Frahm, Robert A."Textbook Case Of Sticker Shock"
Hartford Courant (2005) n. pag. Online. Internet. January 19, 2005 Prystay, Cris "As math skills slip, U.S. schools
seek answers from Asia"
SFgate & The Wall Street Journal (2004) n. pag. Online. Internet.
December 13, 2004 Finn, Jr, Chyester E., and Diane Ravitch"The
Mad, Mad, World of Textbook Adoption" The
Thomas B. Fordham Institute (2004) n. pag. Online. Internet. September
29, 2004 Carlin ,Dan "Textbook prices squeeze student wallets" Arizona
Republic (2004) n.pag. Online. Internet. September 14, 2004 Janet Elliott, and ZuÑiga, Jo Ann "New
sex-ed texts that omit contraception debated" Houston
Chronicle (2004)n. pag. Online. Internet. September 9, 2004 Sommer, Mark"Textbooks - a click away" Buffalo
News (2004) n. pag. Online. internet. August 31, 2004 "Battle over Texas sex-ed textbooks" CNN.com & Reuters (2004) n. pag. Online. Internet. August 5, 2004 Elliott, Jane "Closing of book depository has
schools worried" Houston
Chronicle (2004) n. apg. Online. Internet. June 14, 2004 Portner, Jessica "California debate on textbook costs
draws U.S. interest" Mercury News (2004) n. pag. Online.
Internet. June 12, 2004 Cole, Caroline Louise "Funding derails
laptop program" Boston Globe (2004) n. pag. Online. Internet. June
1, 2004 Hurst, Marianne D. " Textbook Shortages
Spur Digital Alternatives" Education Week (2004) n. pag.
Online. Internet. May 5, 2004 Portner, Jessica "Bill aims to cut state's textbook
costs"
Mercury News (2004) n. pag. Online. Internet. April 19, 2004 "College textbook costs skyrocketing Study finds extras,
new editions drive prices up" CNN.com & AP (2004) April
8, 2004 Bulwa, Demian "Textbook publisher to print cheaper
versions" San Fransisco Chronicle (2004) n. pag: A-27 Online.
Internet. February 13, 2004 Hupp, Staci "Publishers cheating students, study says" Desmoines
Iowa Register (2004) n. pag. Online. Internet. January 30, 2004 Fairchild, Merriah "Rip Off-101 How the current practices
of the TextBook Industry drive up the costs of textbooks" pirg.org (2004)
n. pag. Online. Internet. January 29, 2004 "Texas textbook vote ruffles religious activists" CNN.com & AP (2003) n. pag. Online. Internet. November 6, 2003 "School laptops losing luster Tight budgets squeeze
programs"
CNN.com & AP (2003) n. pag. Online. Internet. October 22, 2003 Wian, Casey "Some educators take issue with textbooks" CNN.com (2003): n. pag. Online. Internet. October 15, 2003 Vogel, Anita "Textbook Changes Draw Charges of Political
Correctness"
Foxnews.com(2003): n. pag. Online. Internet. May 1 2003 "Science Textbooks Full of Errors" ABCNews.com & AP(2001):
n. pag. Online. Internet. 2001 Bradley, Ann "Science Group Finds Middle School Textbooks Inadequate"
Education week (1999): n. pag. Online. Internet. 1999 "Textbooks Riddled With Errors: Do you know what your children are
reading?" Center for Education Reform (1999): n. pag. Online.
Internet. April 1999 Manzo, Kathleen Kennedy"States Setting Strategies To Reduce Mistakes
in Textbooks" Education week (1999): n. pag. Online. Internet.
June 2 1999 Smillie, Dirk"The Great American Textbook Scandal" Forbes (2000):
n. pag. Online 2000 |
